Commercial Union ( AVIVA CGNU Group ) Consumers' Forum

Including Commercial Union, General Accident, Norwich Union
A forum on consumer rights, corporate governance and business ethics

Welcome  Companies  Consumer Information  Consumer Survey

Claim Experiences  Press Releases  Speakers' Corner  Related Links   Home


Problems experienced by Guardian Insurance policy holder
"We would have been better off without insurance than to be insured by Guardian Insurance."



Personal Information:

Name: Ami Maishlish
Location: Ontario, Canada
Email: ami@lifeguide.com

Insurance Information

Name of insurance company: Guardian Insurance Company of Canada
Policy rating: very bad

Claim Information:

Claim rating: very dissatisfied
Size of claim: less than $10,000
Name of insurance agent: Top Hat Insurance Brokers
Agent rating: average
Name of adjuster: William Ballentine
Adjuster rating: very bad
Public adjuster: No
Restoration by Ins. Contr.: No
Name of insurance company's contractor:
Contractor rating: average

Improvements that they would like to see:

Guardian Insurance acted in a heavy handed, callous and crass manner. It denied a valid claim and relied on what appeared to them to be lack of resources to fight them in court. Guardian Insurance Company's behavior and denial of its reponsibilities under the policy caused additional damages and legal costs that are now in excess of $100,000 and continuing to mount.

We would have been better off without insurance than to be insured by Guardian Insurance


Welcome  Companies  Consumer Information  Consumer Survey

Claim Experiences  Press Releases  Speakers' Corner  Related Links   Home


Commercial Union ( CGNU Group ) Consumers' Forum
c/o B.Shuttleworth
P.O.Box 235
Postal Station E
772 Dovercourt Rd.
Toronto, Ontario
Canada, M6H 2V0
brefni@cuconsumers.org


Terms of Use

copyright © 1997-1999 by Brefni Shuttleworth